Mystery Fleece Pullover
Mystery Fleece Pullover
Mystery Fleece Pullover
Mystery Fleece Pullover

Mystery Fleece Pullover

This is a premade item that will ship within 2-3 business days.
Regular price $55.00 Sale price $43.49 Save $11.51

Only 2 items in stock!

Having trouble finding your favorite? How about a surprise tee ?!? We'll select a design for you so you'll have a fantastic surprise to look for in the mail. Note: Mystery shirts are sold final sale and not eligible for return.

Tired of ordering a cute tee only to find out it's too thin, stiff, or shrinks after the first wash? Looking for a way to share your faith with others, but aren't really sure how? EllyandGrace offers high quality faith apparel, so you can share inspiration and the love of Jesus without sacrificing comfort.

Love our fleece pullovers? Can't decide which one to get? Order from this listing, and you will get a single (1) fleece pullover in the size you choose.

Please keep in mind that fleece pullovers are unisex sized.

Have questions? Please read our Surprise Sale FAQ page before ordering & please note that these items are final sale.

Because we value the uniqueness and individual style of our customers, we don't make most of our shirts until they're ordered. Your order will ship between 4-10 business days after your order is placed (8-10 business days if it's during a sale or holiday). If you need something fast, please order from our Quick Ship section - all items ship within 3 business days! Make sure you choose the Quick Ship color and priority mail! 

We have ladies fit and unisex fit styles. Please check the size chart below to ensure the perfect fit for you! Measure a shirt you love at home, and keep your measurements - those will help you find the right size in all of our styles! 

We send each order neatly wrapped in tissue paper, along with a business card, thank you card, and inspirational postcard to pass along to a friend or keep for yourself. We appreciate our customers so much and feel this is a small way we can make them feel special!

Have questions? We're happy to help!
>> 636-229-1617 or

We hand make each shirt design, and all the other items are crafted and shipped directly to you from Missouri. Shirts take on average 6-10 business days to be shipped. During the holiday season, you may see up to an additional 1-2 day delay.

After that, shipping takes 4-6 days, but you can choose priority shipping at checkout. (this does not affect processing time)

If you have any questions about the status of your order, please email

Thank you for shopping small! 

Please note- all international orders are taking on average 6-8 weeks to reach their destinations. We appreciate your patience. 

We know buying online can be difficult! So, we offer exchanges of unworn/unwashed apparel as long as the size or color is still in stock, within 15 days from the delivery confirmation date. 

You have 2 easy options:

1) Store Credit

Is it the wrong color, style or size? Let us know, and we will send you a store credit for the products you purchased (shipping costs are nonrefundable). We will also send you a free return shipping label. Once we receive your unworn/unwashed shirt(s) with the tags still on, we will send you your store credit. The deadline to request store credit is 15 days from the delivery confirmation date.

There is a maximum of 2 exchanges with store credit per order.

2) Refund

Can’t find something that will work? We will refund payment method for the item(s), minus a $5 restocking fee per item purchased and the cost of return shipping. We will also send you a return shipping label. Once we receive your unworn/unwashed shirt(s) with the tags still on, we will send you your refund. The deadline to request a refund is 15 days from the delivery confirmation date.

Please note that “last chance” and sale items/grab bags are final sale and are not eligible for returns.

Customer Reviews

Based on 144 reviews
Donna Patton (Broken Arrow, OK, US)
Fit: As Expected
In Love!

Recently received my Elly and Grace shirt and sweatshirt. I'm in love with this product! Comfortable, beautiful, and so easy to wear! I have psoriasis and some clothes I just can't wear. These are so soft and fit nicely. I will order more from EllyandGrace!🥰💝

Kelly McTier (Tucker, GA, US)
Fit: As Expected
Awesome customer service and awesome product!

I am very pleased with the level of customer service and the personal touches from this company. Handwritten notes, emails...I felt like part of the family. Super soft sweatshirt too. Would definitely purchase something from Elly and Grace again.

Barb (New Albany, OH, US)
Fit: As Expected

Beautiful and thoughtful packaging, the sweatshirt is so soft and comfy....and the scripture verse just as it should be! Will purchase from them again!

Kati (Portland, OR, US)
Fit: As Expected
Soft and perfect!!

I love it. Crazy comfortable and just what I wanted.

Martha J (Port Ludlow, WA, US)
Fit: Slightly Small
Want to love

I got this in the Navy because I wanted to try the regular sweatshirt (I have the hoody from last fall and love it) but this one doesn't fit the same. I,ordered my same size, Large, and it's a bit snug in my abs area. Granted I've gained some weight but it just fits differently than the fleece hoody. Will still keep just beware of size.