MYSTERY Premium Oatmeal Hoodie

MYSTERY Premium Oatmeal Hoodie

Handmade to order item
This is a handmade to order item that takes 6-10 business days to ship. Need it faster? Check out our QuickShip items
Regular price $49.99 Sale price $29.99 Save $20.00

☑️  Premium fit and feel - MADE IN THE USA 
☑️  Cozy and lightweight unisex fit - perfect for lounging or wearing out and about
☑️  Stylish twist on bottom for added personality
☑️  Handprinted design with a premium lightweight feel that’s designed to last, printed & shipped from MO 🇺🇸💜


The design you get will be a mystery!

Want more info?

  • Shown in Oatmeal with black font
  • 74% rayon, 21% polyester, 5% spandex
  • Design © Brenna with EllyandGrace
  • Have Questions? 636-229-1617 or

We hand make each shirt design, and all the other items are crafted and shipped directly to you from Missouri. Shirts take on average 6-10 business days to be shipped. During the holiday season, you may see up to an additional 1-2 day delay.

After that, shipping takes 4-6 days, but you can choose priority shipping at checkout. (this does not affect processing time)

If you have any questions about the status of your order, please email

Thank you for shopping small! 

Please note- all international orders are taking on average 6-8 weeks to reach their destinations. We appreciate your patience. 

We know buying online can be difficult! So, we offer exchanges of unworn/unwashed apparel as long as the size or color is still in stock, within 15 days from the delivery confirmation date. 

You have 2 easy options:

1) Store Credit

Is it the wrong color, style or size? Let us know, and we will send you a store credit for the products you purchased (shipping costs are nonrefundable). We will also send you a free return shipping label. Once we receive your unworn/unwashed shirt(s) with the tags still on, we will send you your store credit. The deadline to request store credit is 15 days from the delivery confirmation date.

There is a maximum of 2 exchanges with store credit per order.

2) Refund

Can’t find something that will work? We will refund payment method for the item(s), minus a $5 restocking fee per item purchased and the cost of return shipping. We will also send you a return shipping label. Once we receive your unworn/unwashed shirt(s) with the tags still on, we will send you your refund. The deadline to request a refund is 15 days from the delivery confirmation date.

Please note that “last chance” and sale items/grab bags are final sale and are not eligible for returns.

Customer Reviews

Based on 9 reviews
Jean Pruszkowski (Las Vegas, NV, US)
Fit: As Expected

Y’all. This shirt is SO much cuter in person!! Obviously I thought it was cute in the photo or I wouldn’t have bought it, but wow. It’s super soft, fits great, and the coziest thing I now own. I’m obsessed!

Sara (Millersburg, OH, US)
Fit: As Expected
Very Soft and Comfortable

This is incredibly soft, both inside and out. It is of a lighter-weight material than their other hoodies but still is perfect for these autumn days.

Sandy (Alexandria, VA, US)
Fit: Too Large
It was a surprise!

It was so funny, when I opened my package I thought, “I didn’t order that”, forgetting it was a mystery item! Admittedly, while I love what’s written on it and it’s amazingly soft, it’s very big on me and has this twist (intentional) on the hem I’m not nuts about. But the softness wins out!

Sharon (Dallas, TX, US)
Fit: Slightly Large
A true mystery received

I had ordered the MYSTERY Premium Oatmeal Hoodie from Elly and Grace. I tracked the shipping and my order actually arrived two days earlier than expected. When I opened my order to see what design I would receive, I was very surprised that the MYSTERY hoodie I received was a One Nation Under God Camo Print hoodie! While surprised, I just figured it was a substitution; and when I tried it on I was very pleased-- possibly even more pleased than if I had received the Oatmeal as expected. The fit is VERY roomy/oversized but I think it is going to prove to be the perfect lightweight layer for Spring, and for evenings through the Summer. Actually, despite how oversized the hoodie is, the arms are actually the perfect length for me (size M as ordered)

Cashmir (Shreveport, LA, US)
Fit: Slightly Large
Be still my heart ❤️

Love this shirt!!! Soft, comfortable.... just what I was hoping for. Should have gotten 1 size smaller as it runs a little big But I still love it.